Gymnasts Who Have Won the Most Medals in Event Finals

This is a list of career medal leaders at the World Championships/Olympics when only medals won on in Event Finals are counted. Other articles in this series can be found below:

All-Around
Vault
Uneven Bars
Balance Beam
Floor Exercise

NameCountryMedals
Simone BilesUnited States25
Larissa LatyninaSoviet Union19
Svetlana KhorkinaRussia15
Gina GogeanRomania13
Ludmilla TurischevaSoviet Union11
Oksana ChusovitinaSoviet Union
Germany
Uzbekistan
11
Vera CaslavskaCzechoslovakia11
Aliya MustafinaRussia10
Daniela SilivasRomania10
Lavinia MilosoviciRomania10
Ecaterina SzaboRomania9
Elena ShushunovaSoviet Union9
Nastia LiukinUnited States9
Nellie KimSoviet Union9
Rebeca AndradeBrazil9
Eva BosakovaCzechoslovakia8
Olga KorbutSoviet Union8
Shannon MillerUnited States8
Simona AmanarRomania8
Agnes KeletiHungary7
Jade CareyUnited States7
Maxi GnauckEast Germany7
Nadia ComaneciRomania7
Tamara ManinaSoviet Union7
Alicia SacramoneUnited States6
Andreea RaducanRomania6
Beth TweddleUnited Kingdom6
Catalina PonorRomania6
Cheng FeiChina6
Emilia EberleRomania6
Erika ZucholdEast Germany6
Karin JanzEast Germany6
Lilia PodkopayevaUkraine6
Natalia KuchinskayaSoviet Union6
Svetlana BoginskayaSoviet Union6
Elena ZamolodchikovaRussia5
Helena RakoczyPoland5
Henrietta OnodiHungary5
Keiko IkedaJapan5
Mai MurakamiJapan5
Maria GorokhovskayaSoviet Union5
Nina DerwaelBelgium5
Polina AstakhovaSoviet Union5
Sofia MuratovaSoviet Union5
Steffi KrakerEast Germany5
Zinaida VoroninaSoviet Union5
Aly RaismanUnited States4
Angelina MelnikovaRussia4
Cristina BontasRomania4
Dominique DawesUnited States4
Hong Un JongNorth Korea4
Larissa PetrikSoviet Union4
Lavinia AgacheRomania4
Maria PasekaRussia4
Sui LuChina4
Sunisa LeeUnited States4
Tatiana GutsuSoviet Union4
Vanessa FerrariItaly4
Ann-Sofi PetterssonSweden3
Aurelia DobreRomania3
Chellsie MemmelUnited States3
Dagmar KerstenEast Germany3
Deng LinlinChina3
Dina KochetkovaRussia3
Elena DavydovaSoviet Union3
Elena MukhinaSoviet Union3
Gabriela PotoracRomania3
He KexinChina3
Julianne McNamaraUnited States3
Kim ZmeskalUnited States3
Lauren MitchellAustralia3
Ling JieChina3
Ludmila EzhovaRussia3
Ma YanhongChina3
Margit KorondiHungary3
Mary Lou RettonUnited States3
McKayla MaroneyUnited States3
Melita RuhnRomania3
Mo HuilanChina3
Natalia ShaposhnikovaSoviet Union3
Pauline SchaeferGermany3
Rebecca BrossUnited States3
Sandra IzbasaRomania3
Shawn JohnsonUnited States3
Tatiana LysenkoSoviet Union3
Vlasta DekanovaCzechoslovakia3
Ana PorgrasRomania2
Aniko DuczaHungary2
Annia HatchCuba
United States
2
Betty OkinoUnited States2
Bi WenjingChina2
Boriana StoyanovaBulgaria2
Courtney KupetsUnited States2
Daria SpiridonovaRussia2
Ekaterina LobaznyukRussia2
Elena GomezSpain2
Elena PiskunBelarus2
Elena ProdunovaRussia2
Fan YilinChina2
Gertrude KolarAustria2
Giulia SteingruberSwitzerland2
Hana RicnaCzechoslovakia2
Huang HuidanChina2
Irina PervuschinaSoviet Union2
Jordan ChilesUnited States2
Kathy JohnsonUnited States2
Kaylia NemourAlgeria2
Ksenia AfanasyevaRussia2
Kui YuanyuanChina2
Kyla RossUnited States2
Larisa IordacheRomania2
Liu TingtingChina2
Liu XuanChina2
Lu LiChina2
Madison KocianUnited States2
Maria NeculitaRomania2
Morgan HurdUnited States2
Mykayla SkinnerUnited States2
Olesia DudnikSoviet Union2
Olga MostepanovaSoviet Union2
Qiu QiyuanChina2
Sanne WeversNetherlands2
Shilese JonesUnited States2
Stella ZakharovaSoviet Union2
Tamara LazakovichSoviet Union2
Tamara LyukhinaSoviet Union2
Teodora UngureanuRomania2
Viktoria KomovaRussia2
Wei XiaoyuanChina2
Yang YilinChina2
Yao JinnanChina2
Yeo Seo JeongSouth Korea2
Zhou YaqinChina2
Alexa MorenoMexico1
Alexandra EremiaRomania1
Alexandra LemoineFrance1
Alexandra MarinescuRomania1
Alice D’AmatoItaly1
Amy ChowUnited States1
Amy TinklerUnited Kingdom1
Ana BarbosuRomania1
Ana PadurariuCanada1
Anastasia IlyankovaRussia1
Andreea CacoveanRomania1
Anna PavlovaRussia1
Annelore ZinkeEast Germany1
Ariella KaslinSwitzerland1
Asia D’AmatoItaly1
Ashley PostellUnited States1
Bai YawenChina1
Becky DownieUnited Kingdom1
Birgit RadochlaEast Germany (EUA)1
Bozena PerdykulovaCzechoslovakia1
Brandy JohnsonUnited States1
Carly PattersonUnited States1
Carola DombeckEast Germany1
Cassy VericelFrance1
Cathy RigbyUnited States1
Chen YongyanChina1
Christine SchmittEast Germany1
Claudia FragapaneUnited Kingdom1
Coline DevillardFrance1
Daiane Dos SantosBrazil1
Dana SofronieRomania1
Daniele HypolitoBrazil1
Diana ChelaruRomania1
Diana DudevaBulgaria1
Dominique MoceanuUnited States1
Dorte ThummlerEast Germany1
Dumitrita TurnerRomania1
Ekaterina KalinchukSoviet Union1
Elena EreminaRussia1
Elena LeusteanuRomania1
Elisabeth SeitzGermany1
Ellie BlackCanada1
Ellie DownieUnited Kingdom1
Elvira SaadiSoviet Union1
Elyse Hopfner-HibbsCanada1
Emilie Le PennecFrance1
Eugenia GoleaRomania1
Evy BerggrenSweden1
Fan DiChina1
Fan YeChina1
Flavia SaraivaBrazil1
Gabriele FahnrichEast Germany1
Galina MinaichevaSoviet Union1
Galina ShamraiSoviet Union1
Guan ChenchenChina1
Hazuki WatanabeJapan1
Hollie ViseUnited States1
Hong Su JongNorth Korea1
Huang MandanChina1
Huang QiushuangChina1
Irina KrasnyanskayaUkraine1
Irina YarodskayaUkraine1
Isabelle SeverinoFrance1
Ivana HongUnited States1
Jade BarbosaBrazil1
Jana BiegerUnited States1
Jessica GadirovaUnited Kingdom1
Ji LiyaChina1
Jordyn WieberUnited States1
Kang Yun MiNorth Korea1
Katalin MakrayHungary1
Katie HeenanUnited States1
Kayla WilliamsUnited States1
Kim Gwang SukNorth Korea1
Koko TsurumiJapan1
Ksenia SemenovaRussia1
Laurie HernandezUnited States1
Leanne WongUnited States1
Li ShanshanChina1
Li ShijiaChina1
Li YifangChina1
Licia MacchiniItaly1
Lidia IvanovaSoviet Union1
Ludivine FurnonFrance1
Luo LiChina1
Luo RuiChina1
Lyubov BurdaSoviet Union1
Lyubov SheremetaUkraine1
Maggie NicholsUnited States1
Manila EspositoItaly1
Marcia FrederickUnited States1
Margarita NikolaevaSoviet Union1
Maria FilatovaSoviet Union1
Maria OlaruRomania1
Marja NuttiItaly1
Marta EgervariHungary1
Matulda PalfyevaCzechoslovakia1
Meng FeiChina1
Mirela PascaRomania1
Monica RosuRomania1
Natalia BobrovaRussia1
Natalia IlienkoSoviet Union1
Natalia ZiganshinaRussia1
Nina BocharovaSoviet Union1
Oana BanRomania1
Oana PetrovschiRomania1
Oksana FabrichnovaRussia1
Oksana OmelianchikSoviet Union1
Olga KarasevaSoviet Union1
Olga Lemhenyi-TassHungary1
Olga RoschupkinaUkraine1
Olga StrazhevaSoviet Union1
Patricia MorenoSpain1
Phan Thi Ha ThanhVietnam1
Phoebe MillsUnited States1
Regina GrabolleEast Germany1
Renske EndelNetherlands1
Rusudan SikharulidzeSoviet Union1
Samantha SheehanUnited States1
Shallon OlsenCanada1
Shoko MiyataJapan1
Simona PaucaRomania1
Sophie SchederGermany1
Stefania ReindlowaPoland1
Steliana NistorRomania1
Sun XiaojiaoChina1
Suzanne HarmesNetherlands1
Tabea AltGermany1
Taniko MitsukuriJapan1
Tang XijingChina1
Tatiana NabievaRussia1
Tereza KocisYugoslavia1
Terin HumphreyUnited States1
Tracee TalaveraUnited States1
Ulrike KlotzEast Germany1
Urara AshikawaJapan1
Vera CernaCzechoslovakia1
Verona van de LeurNetherlands1
Wu JianiChina1
Yang YunChina1
Youna DufournetFrance1
Zhou DuanChina1
Zoya GrancharovaBulgaria1
Last Update: 2024 Olympics (AA, VT, UB, BB, FX + CAS Ruling added)

5 thoughts on “Gymnasts Who Have Won the Most Medals in Event Finals

  1. Mike:  This is a nice treatment. 

    I know you don’t focus on the men much, if at all, in your blog, but I thought that I would share that I did something *similar* for the men.  Also, in my own writings which are scattered (I don’t have my own website as I don’t have the money or the savvy for it), I have increasingly incorporated the importance of the fact of Vitaly Scherbo being the only male gymnast ever to win all 8 World and/or Olympic titles.  I didn’t realize that there wasn’t a properly cited source for that fact in his Wikipedia bio, and the even bigger shock was that on the Wikipedia article for the Republic of Belarus, no mention of him nor of his country’s former greats in Artistic Gymnastics was mentioned within the “Culture-Sport” subsection, so I made a little insertion there with the properly cited source from a Las Vegas newspaper (Scherbo has a gym in that city).  There is such a shortage of gymnastics data and facts from which one can easily cite into the places where it would be needed/helpful on Wikipedia and elsewhere, especially whereas compared to sports like Football, Baseball, Tennis, Hockey, so I was extremely relieved to find the Las Vegas newspaper article on him.

    I *USED* to have a hard drive that had a TON of work I did related to gymnastics history and data, but it is gone.  Some things were such a lot of work that reconstructing them is too daunting for me for right now.  However, the collection of things you have on here, as well as being curious about who would be closest to Scherbo in such a schema, inspired me to put together a list.  Over yesterday evening and today I have culled all the data for the men and women.  What I wanted to know was which men and which women have won a World Championship and/or Olympic individual title in more than one event (AA & EFs).  I discovered that there were 84 men and 52 women who have done this – that is, if my calculations are correct.  I checked and double-checked and triple-checked the data that I culled and am satisfied that what I am presenting is correct, although it is entirely possible that in the earliest stage (data culling) that I accidentally made an omission or two.

    For the men, which present more problems that the women due to the longer and more complicated history, I have had to nuance it more than for the women.  During the 1st 4 World Championships (1903, 1905, 1907, 1909), there seems to have been an inconsistency in which apparatuses were used.  It wasn’t until the 5th Worlds in 1911 that all 4 classic apparatuses (Pommel Horse, Rings, Parallel Bars, Horizontal Bar) were used, and used consistently.  (One of many things I discovered when putting this data together is that the ONLY 2 apparatuses that have been involved at EVERY Worlds/Olympics where individual medals on them were at stake, WERE BOTH BARS – Parallel and Horizontal).  Anyway…also, it wasn’t until 1924 that apparatus medals were consistently awarded at the Olympics, and it wasn’t until the 1932 Olympics that we have the medal format that we see now – AA, and all 6 apparatuses.  Because, during the Interwar Period, there was a period of time where the opportunity to win medals on FX and VT was halved compared to the other apparatuses, I decided that whereas those gymnasts who DID win FX and VT medals during this Interwar period were concerned, I counted that as only half a medal, in order to be fair to those who retired too early to be able to win them, and other similar reasons, and that half a medal works into the percentage of total titles they won and affects how they are stratified within the various sub-tiers.  So, anybody who made their World/Olympic debut before 1932 who won a VT or FX medal either before or after, they are given only half the credit so as to be fair to the rest of the individuals from that timeframe.

    So, I arranged this list of 84 into 7 tiers, with the main underlying principle of % of total available titles determining the stratification.  For anybody who made their debut before 1932, I count the total number of possible individual medals out of 5.  For anybody who made their debut in 1932 or later, I count the total number of possible individual medals out of 7.  Within each of these 7 tiers, there are sub-tiers, depending on the total percentage they won.  Also, I give AA medals greater importance than EF medals and use them to break ties and stratify the tiers in a more nuanced way. 

    For example, Tier 1 is the “100%’ers’, of which there is only 1 – Scherbo.  Tier 2 is the “Minus 1’ers”, of which there are only 3.  Theoretically, within Tier 2, there are multiple sub-tiers, with preference for anybody who won 6/7 over anybody who won 4/5, and within that 6/7 sub-tier, there is a split between those who won an AA medal and those who didn’t.  Because there are so few people on tier 2, and also because it was easier to accomplish this in the Pre-WWI and Interwar Era, there is only one sub-tier represented.  However, in Tiers 3-7, there are multiple populated sub-tiers, except for Tier 5 – that’s just the way it worked out.

    Lastly, I should add that THIS IS NOT AN ALL-TIME RANKING!!!  I repeat, THIS IS NOT AN ALL-TIME RANKING!!!  It is merely a substantively meaningful data set, albeit a quite imperfect one.  Without pointing out some obvious backwards-looking or unjust manifestations within the data, itself, or singling anybody out for positive/negative comment, I should also point out that NUMEROUS Olympic All-Around Champions are completely absent from this list.  This was the case for the women, too, which I shall share next.  I should also add that, yes, I did include the Alternate Olympics for both 1980 and 1984.

    So, without any further ado, here is the breakdown:

    Tier 1 (100%’ers):  Scherbo, Vitaly – 7 – AA, FX, PH, RG, VT, PB, HB

    Tier 2 (Minus-1’ers):  Martinez, Joseph – 4 – AA, RG, PB, HB; Stukelj, Leon – 4 – AA, RG, PB, HB; Zampori, Giorgio – 4 – AA, PH, RG, PB. (3 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS IN THIS HIGH TIER)

    Tier 3 (70%+’ers):  SUB-TIER A:  Misyutin, Hrihoriy – 5 – AA, FX, RG, VT, HB; Nemov, Alexei – 5 – AA, FX, PH, VT, HB; Shakhlin, Boris – 5 – AA, PH, VT, PB, HB; SUB-TIER B:  (none);  SUB-TIER C:  Mack, Eugen – 3.5 – AA, PH, VT, PB; Primozic, Josip – 3.5 – AA, FX, PH, PB;  SUB-TIER D:  Pelle, Istvan – 3.5 – FX, PH, PB, HB. (7 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS IN THIS HIGH TIER)

    Tier 4 (Majority’ers):  SUB-TIER A:  Lalu, Marcel – 3 – AA, PB, HB; Savolainen, Heikki – 3 – AA, PH, HB; Sumi, Peter – 3 – AA, RG, HB; Torres, Marco – 3 – AA, RG, HB; SUB-TIER B:  (none);  SUB-TIER C:  Andrianov, Nikolai – 4 – AA, FX, RG, VT; Bilozerchev, Dmitry – 4 – AA, PH, RG, HB; Chukarin, Viktor – 4 – AA, PH, VT, PB; Dityatin, Alexander – 4 – AA, RG, VT, PB; Kasamatsu, Shigeru – 4 – AA, FX, VT, HB; Korolyov, Yuri – 4 – AA, FX, RG, VT; Muratov, Valentin – 4 – AA, FX, VT, HB; Uchimura, Kohei – 4 – AA, FX, PB, HB; Voronin, Mikhail – 4 – AA, RG, VT, HB; SUB-TIER D:  Nakayama, Akinori – 4 – FX, RG, PB, HB.  (14 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS IN THIS HIGH TIER)

    PRETTY MUCH ANYBODY ABOVE IN TIERS 1-4 SHOULD BE CONSIDERED GOAT-ISH.  A select few from the bottom 3 tiers also should be.

    Tier 5:  (50%’ers):  Hudec, Alois – 2.5 – AA, FX, RG; Miez, Georges – 2.5 – AA, FX, HB.  (2 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS)

    Tier 6:  (40+%’ers):  SUB-TIER A:  Artemov, Vladimir – 3 – AA, PB, HB; Endo, Yukio – 3 – AA, FX, PB; Gushiken, Koji – 3 – AA, RG, PB; Kato, Sawao – 3 – AA, FX, PB; Kenmotsu, Eizo – 3 – AA, PB, HB; Titov, Yuri – 3 – AA, RG, VT; SUB-TIER B:  Aaltonen, Paavo – 3 – PH, VT, HB; Fei, Tong – 3 – FX, PH, HB; Ning, Li – 3 – FX, PH, RG; Reusch, Michael – 3 – PH, PB, HB; Stalder, Josef – 3 – FX, PH, HB; Yun, Lou – 3 – FX, VT, PB; SUB-TIER C:  Cada, Josef – 2 – AA, HB; Neri, Romeo – 2 – AA, PB; Steiner, Ferdinand – 2 – AA, RG; SUB-TIER D:  Boni, Guido – 2 – RG, PB; Erben, Frantisek – 2 – PH, HB; Eyser, George – 2 – RG, PH; Klinger, Miroslav – 2 – PH, HB; Lux, Joseph – 2 – PH, PB.  (20 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS)

    Tier 7:  (Made-A-Tough-List’ers):  SUB-TIER A:  Dalaloyan, Artur – 2 – AA, FX; Hamm, Paul – 2  – AA, FX; Hashimoto, Daiki – 2 – AA, HB; Huhtanen, Veikko – 2 – AA, PH; Kajitani, Nobuyuki – 2 – AA, RG; Korobchinsky, Igor – 2 – AA, FX; Lehmann, Walter – 2 – AA, RG; Nagornyy, Nikita – 2 – AA, VT; Ruoteng, Xiao – 2 – AA, PH; Schwarzmann, Alfred – 2 – AA, VT; Shinnosuke, Oka – 2 – AA, HB; Wei, Yang – 2 – AA, PB; Xiaoshuang, Li – 2 – AA, FX; SUB-TIER B:  Cerar, Miroslav – 2 – PH, PB; Dragulescu, Marian – 2 – FX, VT; Frey, Konrad – 2 – FX, PH; Gebedinger, Ernst – 2 – FX, VT; Jarman, Jake – 2 – FX, VT; Jing, Li – 2 – PH, PB; Kai, Zou – 2 – FX, HB; Kashima, Takehiro – 2 – PH, HB; Kharkov, Sergey – 2 – FX, HB; Kroll, Sylvio – 2 – VT, PB; Mogilny, Valentin – 2 – PH, PB; Ono, Takashi – 2 – VT, HB; Shahinyan, Hrant – 2 – PH, RG; Shirai, Kenzo – 2 – FX, VT; Thomas, Kurt – 2 – FX, HB; Tkachyov, Aleksandr – 2 – PB, HB; Tsukahara, Mitsuo – 2 – VT, HB; Whitlock, Max – 2 – FX, PH; Xiaopeng, Li – 2 – VT, PB; Xuwei, Hu – 2 – PB, HB; Yovchev, Yordan – 2 – FX, RG; Yulo, Carlos – 2 – FX, VT;  SUB-TIER C:  Gajdos, Jan – 2 – AA, FX;  SUB-TIER D:  Hanggi, Hermann – 2 – PH, VT.  (37 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS)

    In Summary:  Tiers 1-7:  1, 3, 7, 14, 2, 20, 37 – 84 TOTAL MALE INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE WON WORLD/OLYMPIC TITLES ON MULTIPLE INDIVIDUAL EVENTS.

    ————-

    Women:

    This is much easier to present.  Less than 2/3 of the data, plus I already articulated why I am doing this and my methodology in the previous post.  Also, no half-medals represented because the history is less problematic. 

    Tier 1:  Caslavska, Vera – 5 – AA, UB, BB, FX; Latynina, Larisa – 5 – AA, VT, UB, BB, FX.  (2 INDIVIDUALS TOTAL)

    Tier 2:  SUB-TIER A:  Biles, Simone – 4 – AA, VT, BB, FX; Boginskaya, Svetlana – 4 – AA, VT, BB, FX; Comaneci, Nadia – 4 AA, UB, BB, FX; Miller, Shannon – 4 – AA, UB, BB, FX; Mostepanova, Olga – 4 – AA, VT, BB, FX; Rakoczy, Helena – 4 –  AA, VT, BB, FX;  SUB-TIER B:  Gnauck, Maxi – 4 – VT, UB, BB, FX; Milosovici, Lavinia – 4 – VT, UB, BB, FX.  (8 INDIVIDUALS TOTAL)

    TIER 3:  SUB-TIER A:  Andrade, Rebeca – 3 – AA, VT, FX; Dekanova, Vlasta – 3 – AA, UB, BB; Johnson-East, Shawn – 3 – AA, BB, FX; Khorkina, Svetlana – 3 – AA, VT, UB; Kim, Nellie – 3 – AA, VT, FX; Liukin, Nastia – 3 – AA, UB, BB; Mustafina, Aliya – 3 – AA, UB, BB; Podkopayeva, Lilia – 3 – AA, VT, FX; Shushunova, Yelena – 3 – AA, VT, FX; Tourischeva, Ludmilla – 3 – AA, BB, FX; Zmeskal, Kim – 3 – AA, BB, FX;  SUB-TIER B:  Gogean, Gina – 3 – VT, BB, FX; Keleti, Agnes – 3 – UB, BB, FX; Korbut, Olga – 3 – VT, BB, FX; Kuchinskaya, Natalia – 3 – UB, BB, FX; Silivas, Daniela – 3 – UB, BB, FX; Szabo, Ecaterina – 3 – VT, BB, FX.  (17 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS)

    TIER 4:  SUB-TIER A:  Amanar, Simona – 2 – AA, VT; Dobre, Aurelia – 2 – AA, BB; Memmel, Chellsie – 2 – AA, UB; Melnikova, Angelina – 2 – AA, VT; Omelianchik, Oksana – 2 – AA, FX; Yurchenko, Natalia – 2 – AA, VT.  SUB-TIER B:  Amanar, Simona – 2 – AA, VT; Dobre, Aurelia – 2 – AA, BB; Memmel, Chellsie – 2 – AA, UB; Melnikova, Angelina – 2 – AA, VT; Omelianchik, Oksana – 2 – AA, FX; Yurchenko, Natalia – 2 – AA, VT.  (23 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS)

    In Summary:  Tiers 1-4:  2, 8, 17, 25 – 52 TOTAL FEMALE INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE WON WORLD/OLYMPIC TITLES ON MULTIPLE INDIVIDUAL EVENTS.

    Like

  2. As always, I am quick to post and then quick to discover errors. For the men, within SUB-TIER 3c, Heida, Anton – 3.5 – AA, PH, VT, HB belongs. Also, at the bottom, I meant to rearticulate both Gajdos and Hanggi at 1.5.

    Again, don’t shoot me. This is NOT an all-time ranking, by any means. It is merely a substantively meaningful if also quite imperfect dataset based strictly on objective criteria.

    Also, for women Tier 4, I meant to type 25 at the end of the paragraph, although I got it right in the summary.

    Like

  3. I should also add that these lists would look VERY different with continental games (Europeans, most notably) and World Cup Finals (1975-2008) added in, and both of those at least halfway belong. The list is very Euro-centric, also, as it took non-Europeans a good bit longer to start participating regularly and mature their programs and make an impact, although part of that is political, of course. I don’t want to make any comments regarding individuals, but I did want to point out trends and these are a couple of articulations I meant to add in earlier.

    Like

  4. CORRECTED/FINALIZED POST (albeit with probably a few “minor” errors).  I didn’t realize, as it appears upon loading this post into your comment, that formatting, (boldface, italics, perhaps even centering), might show up in a comment if used in the preliminary write-up.

    Mike:  This is a nice treatment. 

    I know you don’t focus on the men much, if at all, in your blog, but I thought that I would share that I did something *similar* for the men.  Also, in my own writings which are scattered (I don’t have my own website as I don’t have the money or the savvy for it), I have increasingly incorporated the importance of the fact of Vitaly Scherbo being the only male gymnast ever to win all 8 World and/or Olympic titles.  I didn’t realize that there wasn’t a properly cited source for that fact in his Wikipedia bio, and the even bigger shock was that on the Wikipedia article for the Republic of Belarus, no mention of him nor of his country’s former greats in Artistic Gymnastics was mentioned within the “Culture-Sport” subsection, so I made a little insertion there with the properly cited source from a Las Vegas newspaper (Scherbo has a gym in that city).  There is such a shortage of gymnastics data and facts from which one can easily cite into the places where it would be needed/helpful on Wikipedia and elsewhere, especially whereas compared to sports like Football, Baseball, Basketball, Football, Hockey, Soccer/Futbol, Tennis, so I was extremely relieved to find the Las Vegas newspaper article on him.

    I *USED* to have a hard drive that had a TON of work I did related to gymnastics history and data, but it is gone.  Some things were such a lot of work that reconstructing them is too daunting for me for right now.  However, the collection of things you have on here, as well as being curious about who would be closest to Scherbo in such a schema, inspired me to put together a list.  Over yesterday evening and today I have culled all the data for the men and women.  What I wanted to know was –

    Which men and which women have won a World Championship and/or Olympic individual title in more than one event (AA & EFs)?” 

    I discovered that there were 84 men and 52 women who have done this – that is, if my calculations are correct.  I checked and double-checked and triple-checked the data that I culled and am satisfied that what I am presenting is correct, although it is entirely possible that in the earliest stage (data culling) that I accidentally made an omission or two.

    For the men, which present more problems than the women due to the longer and more complicated history, I have had to nuance it more than for the women.  During the 1st 4 World Championships (1903, 1905, 1907, 1909), there seems to have been an inconsistency in which apparatuses were used.  It wasn’t until the 5th Worlds in 1911 that all 4 classic apparatuses (Pommel Horse, Rings, Parallel Bars, Horizontal Bar) were used, and used consistently.  (One of many things I discovered when putting this data together is that the ONLY 2 apparatuses that have been involved at EVERY Worlds/Olympics where individual medals on them were at stake, WERE BOTH BARS – Parallel and Horizontal).  Anyway…also, it wasn’t until 1924 that apparatus medals were consistently awarded at the Olympics, and it wasn’t until the 1932 Olympics that we have the medal format that we see now – AA, and all 6 apparatuses.  Because, during the Interwar Period, there was a period of time where the opportunity to win medals on FX and VT was halved compared to the other apparatuses, I decided that whereas those gymnasts who DID win FX and VT medals during this Interwar period were concerned, I counted that as only half a medal, in order to be fair to those who retired too early to be able to win them, and other similar reasons, and that half a medal works into the percentage of total titles they won and affects how they are stratified within the various sub-tiers.  So, anybody who made their World/Olympic debut before 1932 who won a VT or FX medal either before or after, they are given only half the credit so as to be fair to the rest of the individuals from that timeframe.

    So, I arranged this list of 84 into 7 tiers, with the main underlying principle of % of total available titles determining the stratification.  For anybody who made their World/Olympic debut before 1932, I count the total number of possible individual medals out of 5.  For anybody who made their debut in 1932 or later, I count the total number of possible individual medals out of 7.  Within each of these 7 tiers, there are sub-tiers, depending on the total percentage they won.  Also, I give AA medals greater importance than EF medals and use them to break ties and stratify the tiers in a more nuanced way. 

    For example, Tier 1 is the “100%’ers’, of which there is only 1 – Scherbo.  Tier 2 is the “Minus 1’ers”, of which there are only 3.  Theoretically, within Tier 2, there are multiple sub-tiers, with preference for anybody who won 6/7 over anybody who won 4/5, and within each of those sub-tiers, there is a split (another sub-tier) between those who won an AA medal and those who didn’t – hence up to 4 sub-tiers per tier.  Because there are so few people on tier 2, and also because it was easier to accomplish this in the Pre-WWI and Interwar Eras, there is only one sub-tier represented.  However, in Tiers 3-7, there are multiple populated sub-tiers, except for Tier 5 – that’s just the way it worked out.

    Lastly, I should add that THIS IS NOT AN ALL-TIME RANKING!!!  I repeat, THIS IS NOT AN ALL-TIME RANKING!!!  It is merely a substantively meaningful data set, albeit a quite imperfect one, created according to certain objective criteria.  Without pointing out some obvious backwards-looking or unjust manifestations within the data, itself, or singling anybody out for positive/negative comment, I should also point out that NUMEROUS Olympic All-Around Champions are completely absent from this list.  This was the case for the women, too, which I shall share next.  I should also add that, yes, I did include the Alternate Olympics for both 1980 and 1984.

    One last caveat:  I should also add that these lists would look VERY different with continental games (Europeans, most notably) and World Cup Finals (1975-2008) added in, and both of those at least halfway belong. The list is very Euro-centric, also, as it took non-Europeans a good bit longer to start participating regularly and mature their programs and make an impact, although part of that is political, of course.

    So, without any further ado, here is the breakdown:

    MEN:

    Tier 1 (100%’ers):  Scherbo, Vitaly – 7 – AA, FX, PH, RG, VT, PB, HB

    Tier 2 (All-But-1’ers):  Martinez, Joseph – 4 – AA, RG, PB, HB; Stukelj, Leon – 4 – AA, RG, PB, HB; Zampori, Giorgio – 4 – AA, PH, RG, PB. (3 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS IN THIS HIGH TIER)

    Tier 3 (70%+’ers):  SUB-TIER A:  Misyutin, Hrihoriy – 5 – AA, FX, RG, VT, HB; Nemov, Alexei – 5 – AA, FX, PH, VT, HB; Shakhlin, Boris – 5 – AA, PH, VT, PB, HB; SUB-TIER B:  (none);  SUB-TIER C:  Heida, Anton – 3.5 – AA, PH, VT, HB; Mack, Eugen – 3.5 – AA, PH, VT, PB; Primozic, Josip – 3.5 – AA, FX, PH, PB;  SUB-TIER D:  Pelle, Istvan – 3.5 – FX, PH, PB, HB. (7 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS IN THIS HIGH TIER)

    Tier 4 (Majority’ers):  SUB-TIER A:  Lalu, Marcel – 3 – AA, PB, HB; Savolainen, Heikki – 3 – AA, PH, HB; Sumi, Peter – 3 – AA, RG, HB; Torres, Marco – 3 – AA, RG, HB; SUB-TIER B:  (none);  SUB-TIER C:  Andrianov, Nikolai – 4 – AA, FX, RG, VT; Bilozerchev, Dmitry – 4 – AA, PH, RG, HB; Chukarin, Viktor – 4 – AA, PH, VT, PB; Dityatin, Alexander – 4 – AA, RG, VT, PB; Kasamatsu, Shigeru – 4 – AA, FX, VT, HB; Korolyov, Yuri – 4 – AA, FX, RG, VT; Muratov, Valentin – 4 – AA, FX, VT, HB; Uchimura, Kohei – 4 – AA, FX, PB, HB; Voronin, Mikhail – 4 – AA, RG, VT, HB; SUB-TIER D:  Nakayama, Akinori – 4 – FX, RG, PB, HB.  (14 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS IN THIS HIGH TIER)

    PRETTY MUCH ANYBODY ABOVE IN TIERS 1-4 SHOULD BE CONSIDERED GOAT-ISH.  Several from the bottom 3 tiers also should be.

    Tier 5:  (50%’ers):  Hudec, Alois – 2.5 – AA, FX, RG; Miez, Georges – 2.5 – AA, FX, HB.  (2 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS)

    Tier 6:  (40+%’ers):  SUB-TIER A:  Artemov, Vladimir – 3 – AA, PB, HB; Endo, Yukio – 3 – AA, FX, PB; Gushiken, Koji – 3 – AA, RG, PB; Kato, Sawao – 3 – AA, FX, PB; Kenmotsu, Eizo – 3 – AA, PB, HB; Titov, Yuri – 3 – AA, RG, VT; SUB-TIER B:  Aaltonen, Paavo – 3 – PH, VT, HB; Fei, Tong – 3 – FX, PH, HB; Ning, Li – 3 – FX, PH, RG; Reusch, Michael – 3 – PH, PB, HB; Stalder, Josef – 3 – FX, PH, HB; Yun, Lou – 3 – FX, VT, PB; SUB-TIER C:  Cada, Josef – 2 – AA, HB; Neri, Romeo – 2 – AA, PB; Steiner, Ferdinand – 2 – AA, RG; SUB-TIER D:  Boni, Guido – 2 – RG, PB; Erben, Frantisek – 2 – PH, HB; Eyser, George – 2 – RG, PH; Klinger, Miroslav – 2 – PH, HB; Lux, Joseph – 2 – PH, PB.  (20 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS)

    Tier 7:  (Made-A-Tough-List’ers):  SUB-TIER A:  Dalaloyan, Artur – 2 – AA, FX; Hamm, Paul – 2  – AA, FX; Hashimoto, Daiki – 2 – AA, HB; Huhtanen, Veikko – 2 – AA, PH; Kajitani, Nobuyuki – 2 – AA, RG; Korobchinsky, Igor – 2 – AA, FX; Lehmann, Walter – 2 – AA, RG; Nagornyy, Nikita – 2 – AA, VT; Ruoteng, Xiao – 2 – AA, PH; Schwarzmann, Alfred – 2 – AA, VT; Shinnosuke, Oka – 2 – AA, HB; Wei, Yang – 2 – AA, PB; Xiaoshuang, Li – 2 – AA, FX; SUB-TIER B:  Cerar, Miroslav – 2 – PH, PB; Dragulescu, Marian – 2 – FX, VT; Frey, Konrad – 2 – FX, PH; Gebedinger, Ernst – 2 – FX, VT; Jarman, Jake – 2 – FX, VT; Jing, Li – 2 – PH, PB; Kai, Zou – 2 – FX, HB; Kashima, Takehiro – 2 – PH, HB; Kharkov, Sergey – 2 – FX, HB; Kroll, Sylvio – 2 – VT, PB; Mogilny, Valentin – 2 – PH, PB; Ono, Takashi – 2 – VT, HB; Shahinyan, Hrant – 2 – PH, RG; Shirai, Kenzo – 2 – FX, VT; Thomas, Kurt – 2 – FX, HB; Tkachyov, Aleksandr – 2 – PB, HB; Tsukahara, Mitsuo – 2 – VT, HB; Whitlock, Max – 2 – FX, PH; Xiaopeng, Li – 2 – VT, PB; Xuwei, Hu – 2 – PB, HB; Yovchev, Yordan – 2 – FX, RG; Yulo, Carlos – 2 – FX, VT;  SUB-TIER C:  Gajdos, Jan – 1.5 – AA, FX;  SUB-TIER D:  Hanggi, Hermann – 1.5 – PH, VT.  (37 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS)

    In Summary:  Tiers 1-7:  1 + 3 + 7 + 14 +2 + 20 + 37 = 84 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE WON WORLD/OLYMPIC TITLES ON MULTIPLE INDIVIDUAL EVENTS.

    ————-

    WOMEN:

    (This is much easier to present.  Less than 2/3 of the data, plus I already articulated why I am doing this and my methodology in the previous post.  Also, no half-medals represented because the history is less problematic.  Also, no more than 2 sub-tiers per tier.)

    Tier 1:  Caslavska, Vera – 5 – AA, VT, UB, BB, FX; Latynina, Larisa – 5 – AA, VT, UB, BB, FX.  (2 INDIVIDUALS TOTAL)

    Tier 2:  SUB-TIER A:  Biles, Simone – 4 – AA, VT, BB, FX; Boginskaya, Svetlana – 4 – AA, VT, BB, FX; Comaneci, Nadia – 4 AA, UB, BB, FX; Miller, Shannon – 4 – AA, UB, BB, FX; Mostepanova, Olga – 4 – AA, VT, BB, FX; Rakoczy, Helena – 4 –  AA, VT, BB, FX;  SUB-TIER B:  Gnauck, Maxi – 4 – VT, UB, BB, FX; Milosovici, Lavinia – 4 – VT, UB, BB, FX.  (8 INDIVIDUALS TOTAL)

    TIER 3:  SUB-TIER A:  Andrade, Rebeca – 3 – AA, VT, FX; Dekanova, Vlasta – 3 – AA, UB, BB; Johnson-East, Shawn – 3 – AA, BB, FX; Khorkina, Svetlana – 3 – AA, VT, UB; Kim, Nellie – 3 – AA, VT, FX; Liukin, Nastia – 3 – AA, UB, BB; Mustafina, Aliya – 3 – AA, UB, BB; Podkopayeva, Lilia – 3 – AA, VT, FX; Shushunova, Yelena – 3 – AA, VT, FX; Tourischeva, Ludmilla – 3 – AA, BB, FX; Zmeskal, Kim – 3 – AA, BB, FX;  SUB-TIER B:  Gogean, Gina – 3 – VT, BB, FX; Keleti, Agnes – 3 – UB, BB, FX; Korbut, Olga – 3 – VT, BB, FX; Kuchinskaya, Natalia – 3 – UB, BB, FX; Silivas, Daniela – 3 – UB, BB, FX; Szabo, Ecaterina – 3 – VT, BB, FX.  (17 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS)

    TIER 4:  SUB-TIER A:  Amanar, Simona – 2 – AA, VT; Dobre, Aurelia – 2 – AA, BB; Memmel, Chellsie – 2 – AA, UB; Melnikova, Angelina – 2 – AA, VT; Omelianchik, Oksana – 2 – AA, FX; Yurchenko, Natalia – 2 – AA, VT.  SUB-TIER B:  Bosakova, Eva – 2 – BB, FX;  Buttner-Jan, Karin – 2 – VT, UB; Carey, Jade – 2 – VT, FX; Chusovitinia, Oksana – 2 – VT, FX; Fei, Cheng – 2 – VT, FX; Frederick, Marcia – 2 – VT, UB; Izbasa, Sandra – 2 – VT, FX; Kochetkova, Dina – 2 – BB, FX; Manina, Tamara – 2 – BB, FX; Palfyova, Matylda – 2 – VT, FX; Pettersson, Ann-Sofi – 2 – VT, UB; Piskun, Elena – 2 – VT, UB; Ponor, Catalina – 2 – BB, FX; Raducan, Andreea – 2 – BB, FX; Sacramone, Alicia – 2 – VT, FX; Tweddle, Beth – 2 – UB, FX; Yanhong, Ma – 2 – UB, BB; Zamolodchikova, Elena – 2 – VT, FX; Zuchold, Erika – 2 – VT, BB.  (25 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS)

    In Summary:  Tiers 1-4:  2 + 8 +17 + 25 = 52 TOTAL INDIVIDUALS WHO HAVE WON WORLD/OLYMPIC TITLES ON MULTIPLE INDIVIDUAL EVENTS.

    Like

Leave a reply to William Noel Cancel reply